I was 7 years old when this album came out, but the words served as the soundtrack to my late teens; before I’d read about gender, welfare, economic segregation, and revolution; before I had the ‘technical expertise’ to deliver programs for change, at a time when I just felt what social justice was and wanted it.
These lyrics were first sung now 21 years ago in 1988. So this is a part of my scattered catalogue of personal and key moments linked to violence against women. What has happened since 1988 in strides for gender equality, and to counter its most extreme perversion, violence against women?
1991, A House of Lords decision overturned the common law rule that held a man could not be criminally liable for having sex with his wife without her consent. This made marital rape punishable. 1995 In Antigua, the Sexual Offences Act was passed which also prohibits marital rape. In certain circumstances. Such as if the couple has a separation agreement or is divorced. The law is piecemeal and doesn’t affirm women’s rights to absolute bodily integrity.
Feb 2009, photos of Bajan born, pop-star Rihanna’s bruised face circulated the world. Not long afterwards, a colleague of mine described his sleepless night, littered with thumps, slams, and kicks as a man attacked his girlfriend on the other side of a trendy hotel wall, in a ‘safe, tranquil neighbourhood’ of Port of Spain. Later Chris Brown apologized publicly.
2003, I met an ethnic Albanian woman who had survived gang rape by Serbian police in Kosovo. There were 5 of them. She aborted the child of one, and was subsequently called an ‘unreliable’ claimant by the UK immigration department. She and her family had felt her husband’s and children’s broken bodies were enough evidence to secure refugee status, without having to re-live her own sexual torture before them at hearings. It took years of representations and undignified uncertainty for her and her family before finally a concession, with limited relevance to the facts of her case, allowed her to stay in London.
Christmas 2008, an Egyptian lady stood waiting for me outside the front door of a drop-in centre where I worked, her hair wrapped under plastic to shield her from cold raindrops. Her husband had raped and beaten her for years, and she had finally left him with two children. The husband had returned to Egypt, taking his vast wealth, and re-married, abandoning her without money and threatening to kill her if she returned to Cairo for ‘dishonouring’ their marriage. UK law currently prevents non-national women, even those married to UK citizens, from accessing public funds such as housing or income support. This traps many newly married women in situations of violence with nowhere to go. So this frightened lady, having been house detained for years, struggled to explain her story to me in English to protect her children from having to translate it. She had been turned away from basic protection and support. Amnesty International and Black Southall Sisters are holding a mass lobby of UK parliament on 2nd November to push for a change to this law.
These last two tales come from one of the richest countries in the world. A land of chubby bankers and bonuses.
10th June 2009, a decision was made in Opuz v Turkey at the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR). Nahide Opuz proved that Turkish authorities had failed to offer sufficient protection against domestic violence when she and her mom repeatedly reported extreme brutality at the hands of the mother’s husband, until one day her mother was killed. The Court made several important points in its landmark ruling including that when authorities are aware of grave instances of domestic violence, it falls upon them to undertake effective action and waiting for the victim to come forward for protection is not enough. The Court also found that Turkey had failed to protect against discrimination on the basis of gender and held that its failure to protect women against domestic violence breached their right to equal protection of the law, even if unintentionally so. ECHR rulings set a standard for all European member states. These are the kind of legal precedents we should be looking to, to create protective environments for women.
Instead, in 2009 as Antigua and Barbuda is reportedly ranked among the top 50 nations in the UN human development index, we hear stories of rape victims being told to stay at home until morning because there are no police patrols available to pick them up for protection or healthcare. We hear of police raiding nightclubs and attempting to cart dancers, undressed, to Newgate Street, stripping them of dignity they fight to hold onto. You can hear the police snickering and feel their perception of luck as they arrest women without underwear. We hear testimonies of migrant sex workers being raped at knife point, too ashamed to tell their story to police officers who are likely to turn around and say they deserved it, or simply deport them back to the structural poverty they were trying to escape. So afraid that when they come forward it’s too late to take DNA evidence, too late to start emergency contraception or post exposure prophylaxis which could safeguard them against HIV.
As of October 2009, we have 48 recorded sexual offences this year. Last year we had a total of 75. Both these numbers fail to reflect invisible victims, like the rape described above. We hear of there being no consistent protocol for victims who do come forward.
September 2009, An amendment to the Antigua Education Act is tabled which would legally exclude pregnant girls from school. Women’s organisations and feminists react violently. The issue is put on hold.
Another of Tracy Chapman ‘s songs, ‘Across the lines’, speaks to the economic segregation that in 1980’s America divided whites from blacks. 20 years later, what lines are we creating right here in Antigua? Women are divided. Women who don’t get promoted or paid equally, because they are women, still snub fellow women… Women who choose a different method of resisting this same patriarchal system when they wear 6inch heels at night, and then peel crumbled Queen Elizabeth’s, originating from men’s pockets, from the crevices of their bodies to send to their families. Working people draw lines between those born here struggling to make a living, and those living but not born here trying to escape a jagged, less forgiving poverty an island hop away.
Is anyone else as enraged as me at all these walls and lines? I want to know! I want the richest states to offer real refuge to women fleeing violence. I want to bulldoze the system that keeps women poor despite being the backbone of our Caribbean economies. I want to beat power and gender inequalities to a pulp, starting with enforcement of good legislation designed to protect women, and scraping of legislative amendments that seek to perpetuate the poverty cycle; and propose not just to violate a pregnant schoolgirl’s rights to education but to declare class warfare on girls who don’t have money to be flown away for an alternative education. I want police to be respectful of migrant sex workers, and to know that they are highly vulnerable to violence and rape from Antiguan men, and too have a right to police protection. I want legislators to make it the states obligation to protect all women behind walls or attacked in parked cars, or face Court for breach of duty.
Looking back at my reflections on violence against women, there have been moments that generate anger, interspersed with moments of individual victories, hope and progress. Reducing something like violence against women requires dogged persistence, a free mind, and a dash of madness. It’s about smashing down walls, crossing lines, putting women and not moralizing views first, and reaching out to share some of your strength.
These women’s tales scramble my emotions and gnaw at my soul, but their resolute spirits could humble us all. So if we are stronger, more forceful, more angry, more determined, more powerful, together our brains and efforts will one day drop like a ton of bricks, and the perpetrators flailing fists and flaccid bits will be pinned down and controlled.
I’m not writing this to rapists, or those who hit. They can’t be persuaded by fingers on a keyboard. But you can. And so can your decision makers. We are tiptoeing around when together it is our voices that should be feared by men hiding behind masks.
These are just some of my stories from a larger narrative about violence against women. What are yours? Think about it, I bet you have your own. All these stories, these struggles, matter. How will you contribute to the struggle here and now, and end this?
Join us during 16 days of activism to end violence against women, starting November 24th.